The Post-NAR Era — what changed in 2024 and why it matters

Time to complete: 60 minutes Prerequisite: Foundation Lessons 1 and 2 Goal: Understand what changed in real estate in March 2024, why it changed, and how the world looks 18+ months into the new rules. You will know the language of the new buyer agency reality. You will understand why your agent now talks about "compensation conversations" with buyers in a way they didn't two years ago.

Confidence note: The post-NAR Settlement environment is still evolving in 2026. State legislatures are passing laws. The DOJ is investigating buyer agency disclosure practices. MLS-by-MLS rules vary. Treat this lesson as a baseline for the evergreen mechanics; expect the agent or operations manager on your team to update you on tactical specifics. High confidence on the structural changes; moderate confidence on industry-norm specifics that vary by region and brokerage.

Part 1 — What happened, in plain English

For decades, US residential real estate ran on a custom: when a seller listed a house, they agreed to pay a total commission (usually 5–6% of the sale price) and the listing agent split it with whichever buyer's agent brought a buyer. The buyer's side commission was published on the MLS — every buyer's agent could see how much they'd be paid before they showed the home.

This arrangement had two huge effects:

Buyers rarely paid their agent directly. The compensation was baked into the seller's transaction.
Buyer's agents were incentivized by what was on the MLS — show the homes that pay better.

Several class-action lawsuits (the most famous is Sitzer/Burnett v. NAR, decided in late 2023) argued this constituted price-fixing and steered buyers toward higher-commission listings. A federal jury in Missouri agreed and awarded $1.78 billion in damages.

NAR (the National Association of Realtors) settled the broader suite of cases in March 2024 for $418 million, plus rule changes that took effect on August 17, 2024.

The two big rule changes:

Cooperating compensation can no longer be advertised on the MLS. A listing on the MLS can no longer say "seller will pay buyer's agent 2.5%". That number must move off the MLS to other channels (websites, signs, in conversation, etc.).
Buyer's agents must have a signed Buyer Representation Agreement before showing a home. No more touring properties first and figuring out commission later. The agreement must specify how the agent gets paid — and that compensation must be a fixed, knowable amount (not "whatever the seller offers").

Those are the two changes that matter. Everything else in 2026 flows from them.

Part 2 — How a deal actually flows in 2026

Read this comparison carefully. This is what changed.

Pre-Settlement (before August 2024)

Buyer wants a house.
Buyer calls a buyer's agent. They tour homes. No paperwork yet.
Buyer makes an offer. The buyer's agent's commission is "whatever the MLS says" — usually 2.5–3%.
Deal closes. Seller pays both agents from their proceeds.

Post-Settlement (August 2024 onward)

Buyer wants a house.
Buyer calls a buyer's agent. Before any home tour, they must sign a Buyer Representation Agreement that specifies the commission the agent earns and how it's paid.
The agreement might say: "Buyer's agent earns 2.5% of purchase price. Buyer's agent will first attempt to have the seller pay this through the offer. If the seller refuses, buyer pays the difference."
Buyer tours homes. Each home has a different listing situation:

Listing has cooperating compensation offered (advertised through non-MLS channels): seller is willing to pay buyer's agent. Easy.
Listing offers a partial cooperating compensation (e.g., 2% when the BRA says 2.5%): buyer covers the gap.
Listing offers nothing: buyer must pay the full amount or negotiate it into the purchase agreement as a seller concession.

Buyer makes an offer that includes a request for the seller to pay X% to the buyer's agent. Seller can accept, counter, or reject.
Deal closes. Funds flow to whichever party is paying the buyer's agent.

The structural difference: buyer compensation is now a negotiable line item in the offer, not a default. The buyer's agent has to sell their value and justify their fee the way every other professional does — lawyer, doctor, contractor, accountant.

Part 3 — What this means for your agent (and you)

Your agent is now operating in a world where:

Buyer-side commissions are smaller, on average. Most analyst estimates put the average buyer-side commission down 25–50 basis points (i.e., 2.5% commissions are now often 2.0–2.25%). In some markets they've held; in others they've collapsed. Moderate confidence on the size; high confidence on the direction.
Buyer's agents are doing more upfront work for free — touring, advising, doing showings — without the certainty of compensation that used to be there. This puts pressure on the agent to qualify buyers harder before committing.
Listing agents have new conversations with sellers. The seller used to think of total commission as one number; now they think of it as two negotiable numbers. Many sellers now ask "do I have to offer anything to the buyer's agent?" The answer is no — but if they don't, fewer buyers can afford to tour their home. The strategic conversation is different.
Buyer Representation Agreements have a hard cost — buyers occasionally refuse to sign or sign but resent it. Agents are now selling their value during a "buyer consultation" that was previously informal.
Compliance risk is real. Agents who tour buyers without a signed BRA are now exposed. Brokerages have tightened policies. Operations teams (you) are responsible for the paperwork hygiene.

This is the environment you are training in. There is no "going back to the way it used to be." The REVAs and operations people who understand this will be more valuable than ones who don't.

Part 4 — The new vocabulary

A handful of terms came into common use after the Settlement. Know them.

Buyer Representation Agreement (BRA) — also called Buyer's Agency Agreement, Buyer Broker Agreement, BBA, Exclusive Buyer Agency Agreement. The mandatory contract between a buyer and a buyer's brokerage that specifies compensation. Mandatory before showing.

Cooperating Compensation — what a listing brokerage is willing to pay a buyer's brokerage. Used to be on the MLS; now communicated through other channels.

Offer of Compensation — same idea. The amount the listing side offers. Often listed on the brokerage's listing website, in marketing materials, or communicated agent-to-agent.

Concession — money the seller agrees to pay or credit to or for the buyer at closing. Can be used to cover buyer-side commission, closing costs, repair credits, or rate buy-downs. The dominant mechanic for getting buyer commission paid by the seller in a post-Settlement deal: the buyer's offer requests a concession that the buyer then uses to pay their agent.

Touring Agreement / Pre-Showing Agreement — a short-term, single-property version of a BRA used in some markets for first-touch tours where the buyer isn't ready to commit to a full BRA. Allowed in Minnesota.

Compensation Disclosure — the mandatory written disclosure of how the buyer's agent is being compensated. Different from the BRA itself; the BRA is the contract, the compensation disclosure is sometimes a separate form.

Decoupled Commissions — an industry shorthand for the new world where seller-side and buyer-side commissions are negotiated separately and not bundled.

Part 5 — Real scenarios you'll see in your first 90 days

Here are situations you need to recognize and route correctly.

Scenario A — The buyer didn't sign the BRA yet

Buyer's agent says "I'm taking this client to see a house tomorrow at 2pm." Your job: Make sure the BRA is signed before the showing. If it isn't, message the agent: "BRA on file? I don't see one. Want me to send it now?" This protects the brokerage.

Scenario B — Listing shows no offer of compensation

Buyer's agent finds a property the buyer wants. Listing has no advertised offer of compensation. Your job: Help the agent prepare the buyer for two paths: (a) write the offer with a seller concession that covers the buyer-side commission, or (b) buyer pays the commission directly. Pull the listing agent's contact and confirm whether they're willing to entertain a concession.

Scenario C — Buyer asks "why am I paying my agent?"

This is a conversation the agent has, not you. But you may field the email. The shorthand answer: "Your agent's compensation is set in the BRA you signed at the start. We try to negotiate the seller to pay it through a concession. If the seller won't, the BRA controls." Then loop the agent in.

Scenario D — Listing agent asks "what's your buyer's BRA say?"

Your job: Pull the BRA, confirm the compensation amount, and send the agreed-upon language to the listing agent (or have your agent do it). Listing-side agents now ask this routinely so they can advise their seller on the offer.

Scenario E — Compliance flag

Brokerage emails you saying a deal file is missing the BRA. Your job: Find it, confirm the date is before the first showing date, send to compliance. If it's missing or dated wrong, escalate to your agent immediately. This is one of the few situations where you should interrupt your agent regardless of time of day.

Part 6 — What to watch for in the next 12–24 months

The post-Settlement environment is still settling. Things you'll likely see change:

State-level laws. Several states (CA, NY, etc.) have proposed or passed laws codifying or modifying the BRA requirement. Minnesota has not at the time of this writing — the rules in Minnesota flow from the NAR Settlement and brokerage policies.
DOJ scrutiny. The federal Department of Justice has continued to probe buyer agency disclosure practices and may push for further changes.
MLS-level rule variation. Northstar MLS in Minnesota has adopted the NAR Settlement standard policy. Other regional MLSs have variations.
Industry consolidation. Some brokerages will not survive the margin compression. M&A activity is up.
Buyer agent compensation models will keep diversifying. Flat fees, hourly rates, transaction-based fees, and hybrid models will all coexist. Your team's model may change. Stay flexible.

When your agent or operations manager updates a policy, update it in your head. Don't run on yesterday's rules.

Part 7 — How to be the smart REVA in this environment

Three habits separate the average REVA from the one who's invaluable in 2026:

Be the BRA hygiene champion. Every buyer your agent works with must have a signed BRA before showing. You should be the one who tracks this. If you build a habit where your agent never has to think about it, they will love you.
Speak the new language. When you write follow-ups, emails, or summaries, use the terms in this lesson correctly. Buyer's agents and listing agents respect a REVA who knows what an offer of compensation is. They lose respect for one who calls everything "the commission."
Don't speculate. When a buyer asks a complicated question about who's paying whom, don't guess. Loop in the agent. The cost of a wrong answer here is a fair-housing complaint or a lawsuit. The cost of saying "let me have the agent answer that" is zero.

Self-check before you move on

What two rule changes took effect in August 2024 as a result of the NAR Settlement?
What is a Buyer Representation Agreement (BRA), and when must it be signed?
Cooperating compensation used to be advertised where? Where does it live now?
What's a "seller concession" and why is it now the most common mechanic for getting the seller to pay the buyer's agent?
Walk through Scenario A. What do you do?
Why is BRA hygiene a compliance issue, not just a paperwork issue?

When you can answer all six from memory, you are ready for Foundation Lesson 4 — Minnesota specifics.

← The cast of characters and the deal flow

Join free to track progress Glossary — national and regional terms →